Media reports 'magical' government spending

The sins of the mainstream media, which leans so far to the liberal-left you have wonder what holds them up, are not so much what they tell you as what they distort or omit altogether.
Adlai Stevenson’s description of the journalist as one who “separates the wheat from the chaff and then prints the chaff” was never more accurate than in the April 5, 2009 edition of The New York Times. Adam Nossiter’s article, “Louisiana, a Test Case in Federal Aid,” makes lowly chaff seem like nothing less than the cream of the crop. I could have chosen any one of endless examples from the past week but this piece from three years ago has become a classic case of the problem.
Imagine a thief who spends an afternoon pick-pocketing a sizable crowd. In a few hours, he’s nabbed thousands of dollars in cash and a bag full of credit cards. He then spends a small fortune at jewelry stores and makes off with the loot as a suspicious citizen who recognizes him cries, “Stop!”
If Nossiter were covering this little episode, the story in The Times the next day would read: “A Good Samaritan yesterday gave several gem shops a big boost when he bought more diamonds than the stores usually sell in a month. The benefits of the spending binge were confirmed by no less an authority than the store owners themselves, who promise to hire more employees if the generous customer comes back regularly. An obviously disgruntled passerby attempted to interfere in the matter by shouting as the customer left, but he was told by an angry store manager to leave well enough alone.”
Make these substitutions and you have the gist of the article that appeared in The Times: The Good Samaritan is the federal government, the jewelry store is Louisiana and the passerby who tried to rain on their parade is Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal.
The Times story notes that the feds had dumped more than $50 billion in money on Louisiana since Hurricane Katrina. “Indicators suggest,” notes Nossiter, that “dumping a large amount of reconstruction money into a confined space . . . has had a positive outcome.” Apparently, not even the government can spend $50 billion on construction without yielding some construction.
Gov. Jindal raised objections to this “free” money. He warned of “dire consequences” of the federal spending spree. But Nossiter says not to worry: “In Louisiana, the consequences have hardly been dire — just the opposite, in fact.” He’s looking at the few upon whom the money was spent and ignoring all those from whom the money was taken (including future generations to whom Washington is sending most of the bill through its monumental debt).
Sadly, The Times story is typical of what passes these days for mainstream journalism. Its reasoning is so infantile, its evidence so transparent, and its economics so woefully deficient that one can’t help but wonder if it was printed simply to advance somebody’s brainless big government agenda.
***********

(Lawrence W. Reed, a resident of Newnan, is president of the Foundation for Economic Education in Irvington, N.Y., and Atlanta.)



More Opinion

Georgia Says

The Augusta Chronicle, Augusta, Georgia, on proposed Internet rules: Large corporations can't always be trusted to do the right thing. But n ... Read More


A note from the publisher

A lot has occurred at The Newnan Times-Herald over the last few months, and I believe it’s an appropriate time to let you know what we ... Read More


Rants, Raves & Really?!?

A look back at last week’s highs, lows and whatevers: REALLY?!?: Grantville has a new police chief, the third one in about as many yea ... Read More


Georgia Says

The Augusta (Georgia) Chronicle on the Affordable Care Act: A private foundation issued a report claiming 20 million Americans "gained cover ... Read More


‘Murder in Coweta’ has continual silver lining

The killing of farmhand William Turner in 1948 was a tragedy. Turner, who was using the name Wilson Turner, was a young husband and father. ... Read More

Rants, Raves & Really?!?

RAVE: To Alex Ogletree for giving back to his alma mater, Newnan High. Ogletree gave $5,000 to upgrade the NHS weight room. The NFL gave a m ... Read More