Lawmaker wants Georgia to nix federal laws

By Walter C. Jones
Morris News Service
ATLANTA – Georgia would ignore federal laws and presidential orders if a panel of appointees says they're unconstitutional and the General Assembly agrees under legislation introduced Thursday.
Whether states can nullify a federal law without a court striking it down was an issue that sparked the Civil War, and many scholars argue the matter was settled 150 years ago. The courts are the only option for disgruntled states, according to Neil Kinkopf, a constitutional expert at Georgia State University's law school.
"This is the most thoroughly settled question in constitutional law," he said.
However, Rep. Jason Spencer, R-Woodbine, argues nullification was supported by Thomas Jefferson and other founding fathers and that the Civil War didn't change the powers the Constitution gives to the states.
"It's a doctrine I believe is valid," said Spencer, who is a member of the informal Conscience Caucus of conservative legislators.
He sponsored House Bill 352 which would create a 10-member commission to review every new federal law and recommend ones legislators should vote on nullifying. 
"Neither the state nor its citizens shall recognize or be obligated to live under such statute, mandate or executive order," notes the bill.
Georgia has used the courts to try to strike down laws it objects to. For instance, it joined half of the states in asking the U.S. Supreme Court to reject the federal health-reform law known as ObamaCare. That court upheld the bulk of the law, but it agreed with the states about one part that would have withheld Medicaid funds as punishment if states refused to expand that insurance program for the poor. As a result, Gov. Nathan Deal has decided not to expand it here now that there's no penalty.
But the federal courts could be wrong and refuse to reject an unconstitutional law passed by Congress and enforced by the executive branch, Spencer notes.
"Who checks the federal government when all three branches assault the states?" he asks.
The second-term legislator doesn't expect his bill to pass, at least not this year. Instead, he sees it as an opportunity to educate his colleagues during a hearing he expects to get in committee.
In Mississippi where a pair of Tea Party advocates introduced a similar bill, a legislative committee voted it down last week.
"I don't know why we would want to bring that ridicule on Georgia," Kinkopf said.


More Local

Dual enrollment saves GA students college debt

Not only do dual enrollment courses allow high school students to earn college credit early, but those higher-level courses also increase gr ... Read More


CEC students take home most awards in Emmy competition

Students from Central Educational Center garnered the top number of awards – four – of any school with competitors in the 2015 H ... Read More


Natalie Bacho to speak at prayer event Thursday

The National Day of Prayer is Thursday, and events in observance of the day are scheduled in Newnan and Grantville. The theme for 2015 is &l ... Read More


Coweta Commission

CCFD personnel decisions on Tuesday agenda

Action regarding personnel issues at the Coweta County Fire Department is expected to be taken at Tuesday’s meeting of the Coweta Coun ... Read More


NTH Turns 150

1943: Governor Ellis Arnall helping create new Georgia

By Clay Neely clay@newnan.com Less than a year after taking his oath of office, Governor Ellis Arnall had wasted no time. Long regarded as o ... Read More

Dr. Hildebrand distinguished principal

Elm Street Elementary School Principal Dr. Christi Hildebrand was named Georgia’s 2015 National Distinguished Principal earlier this w ... Read More