Domestic Violence

State's high court considers status of permanent protective orders

by Walter C. Jones, Morris News Service

ATLANTA  – Thousands of battered wives across Georgia could be surprised to learn that the permanent protective order courts have issued to keep their husbands or boyfriends away may not be permanent after all.

Monday, the Georgia Supreme Court heard arguments over whether judges should have the power to end the protective orders. There’s never been a case on this particular issue, according to lawyer Brad Sperr.

He is representing Lynda Mandt who got a permanent protective order in 2007 against her boyfriend William Roderick Lovell after four years of hearings. She alleged that, even though he fathered her child, he had repeatedly strangled her, hit her, kicked her stomach while pregnant and threatened to kill her since 2003.

Two years after the order became permanent, Lovell asked a different court to remove it because he had cleaned up his life and never wanted to see her again anyway. He told the new judge he was embarrassed by the court order, and that it kept him from getting a job and dates when people learned of it.

Lovell’s lawyer didn’t show up for Monday’s arguments at the Supreme Court, but several of the justices challenged Sperr about what Mandt wants.

They debated whether the General Assembly had intended it to be permanent, as the name suggests, or if lawmakers expected judges to modify or remove them as they often did under the unwritten common law with permanent injunctions, an older type of court order used more in business cases.

“We can’t assume the legislature wanted to treat it differently,” said Justice Harold Melton.

“They didn’t have to because it’s a matter of common law,” Justice David Nahmias said.

Chief Justice Carol Hunstein, the only woman on the court, noted the Family Violence Act that created the permanent protective orders has no provision for removing them. She said, “The statute is plain on its face, isn’t it?”

Nahmias made up a situation in which a couple that once fought eventually reconciled in their old age. If a permanent protective order could never be changed, then they couldn’t attend a grandchild’s baptism, even with mutual agreement, he said.

Hunstein replied, “Who would make a complaint in that case?”

Sperr told the justices that, at the very least, courts should have to follow some procedures before they can remove a permanent protective order. He recommended they require a waiting period first and determine if the boyfriend or husband had undergone order anger management or psychological counseling.

“There must be substantive, procedural safeguards for these termination actions so they are consistent with the Family Violence Act and will protect victims,” Sperr said. “There must be a minimum, threshold requirement for a termination action that relates to whether or not family violence is going to occur and not simply whether or not a (boyfriend) is burdened.”

Whatever the Supreme Court decides to do, it won’t announce it for about four months. It’s likely that legislators will have a bill drafted by the time they return in January to address whatever the decision is.



More Local

Suspect in Union City killing arrested

The man suspected of killing a Newnan woman in Union City in early April was arrested by authorities in Atlanta late Monday. Irwin Clint Dre ... Read More


Public safety officials converge for Mantracker

Public safety personnel and law enforcement officers from all over Georgia are crowding to Coweta County this week for the 2014 Mantracker P ... Read More


College, career readiness

Coweta schools score higher than state

The Georgia Department of Education released the results of the College and Career Readiness Performance Index earlier this week, and school ... Read More


Suspected robbers extradited to Columbia County

The two suspected armed robbers arrested in Newnan last week were extradited to Columbia County on Monday to face numerous charges. On Monda ... Read More


Community Responds to shootings

Easter event first of several planned

Wet weather nixed the egg hunt at Central Educational Center on Saturday, but the atmosphere at the Community Easter Fest was one of buoyant ... Read More

2 arrested for sale of marijuana

Two people were charged with selling marijuana last week following undercover investigations by the Newnan Police Department, including one ... Read More